Now that we, as a culture, are over the collective disbelief that margarine isn't butter, it's time we wrap our heads around an even more delicious concept: that butter doesn't always mean milk. Proving the point and paving the way for butters of every origin, this pumpkin butter is made with pumpkins, apples, and little else. Enjoy the rich flavor, and strip away the incredulity. It's more than butter; it's the future.

• 8.5 oz
• Ingredients include pumpkin, brown and white sugars, apple juice concentrate, and spices