Mix it Up: The Goat Hill

A bold new take on the classic Manhattan with some mixed whiskeys and added amaro.

The classic Manhattan combination of rye, vermouth, and bitters is a fine go-to for any home bar. But according to Chuck Cerankosky, co-owner and manager of the bar & cocktail programs at Good Luck and Cure in Rochester, N.Y., a little creativity in those base ingredients can give you a deliciously varied repertoire.

By upping your bar’s ante with a few liqueurs and vermouths, your ability to make out-of-the-ordinary classic and new classic cocktails increases exponentially. A bottle of Campari here, one of Fernet Branca or Chartreuse there — all of a sudden you’re handing out Boulevardiers and Greenpoints like some kind of learned mixologist. Or at least, that’s what your friends will think.

Along those same lines, a few variations on the classic Manhattan recipe will give you something excitingly new, like this take called The Goat Hill — served in both of Chuck’s spots.


  • 1 oz. Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye
  • 1 oz. Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch
  • ½ oz. Carpano Antica Sweet Vermouth
  • ¾ oz. Cardamaro
  • 3 dashes The Bitter Truth Lemon Bitters


  1. Combine all the ingredients with ice in a mixing glass.
  2. Stir it all up for at least 30 seconds.
  3. Strain into an Old Fashioned glass with ice.
  4. Garnish with twist of lemon, and enjoy.
More in Wine & Spirits
More from Field Guide
{{ AssociateAccountModalCtrl.data.message }}
{{ AssociateAccountModalCtrl.data.paragraph }}
{{ AssociateAccountModalCtrl.data.error }}

Don't already have a Bespoke Post account?

We've created a brand new Bespoke Post account for you, using the email address: {{ ::$ctrl.userEmail }}
Welcome back
You have an account with us, but haven't set a password yet. Reset your password to log-in.
{{ $ctrl.email }}
Email sent
The {{ ::$ctrl.product.name }} -
For a limited time, get over 20% off one of our favorites (plus, free returns).